This study experimentally examines the use of Ground Granulated Blast Furnace Slag (GGBS) and Fly Ash as partial replacements for cement in M30 grade concrete, focusing on compressive strength and carbonation depth. GGBS replacement levels of 10–70% and Fly Ash replacement levels of 10–40% were considered. The reported compressive-strength measurements were evaluated at 7, 14 and 28 days, while carbonation depth was assessed at the same ages. The highest 28-day compressive strength in the reported GGBS series was 45.5 MPa at 50% replacement. For the Fly Ash series, the highest reported 28-day strength was 41.5 MPa at 30% replacement. Carbonation depth increased with increasing replacement level in both series, reaching 12 mm at 70% GGBS and 10 mm at 40% Fly Ash after 28 days. The results indicate that replacement level influences both strength development and carbonation behaviour; therefore, an optimum mixture should be selected by considering these properties together. The findings are limited to the mix proportions and curing ages reported in this study.
Introduction
Concrete is widely used in construction due to its strength, durability and versatility. However, Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) production consumes significant energy and releases carbon dioxide. Replacing a portion of cement with industrial by-products such as Ground Granulated Blast Furnace Slag (GGBS) and Fly Ash can reduce cement consumption and promote sustainable concrete production.
This study investigates the effects of GGBS and Fly Ash as partial cement replacements in M30-grade concrete. The main aim is to evaluate their influence on compressive strength and carbonation depth at different replacement percentages and curing ages.
The experimental programme considers GGBS replacement levels of 10%–70% and Fly Ash replacement levels of 10%–40%. Compressive strength is measured at 7, 14 and 28 days. Carbonation depth is determined using a 1% phenolphthalein indicator solution, which identifies carbonated and non-carbonated regions through colour changes.
The experimental results indicate that:
GGBS concrete: The maximum 28-day compressive strength is 45.5 MPa at 50% GGBS replacement. Its corresponding carbonation depth is 9 mm.
Fly Ash concrete: The maximum 28-day compressive strength is 41.5 MPa at 30% Fly Ash replacement. Its corresponding carbonation depth is 10 mm.
Carbonation behaviour: Carbonation depth generally increases with increasing replacement percentages of both GGBS and Fly Ash.
Curing age: Compressive strength increases with curing age, while the measured carbonation depth also increases over the reported testing periods.
The comparative results show that the 50% GGBS mixture achieves a higher reported compressive strength and a lower carbonation depth than the 30% Fly Ash mixture. This indicates that GGBS can provide a favourable combination of strength and carbonation performance under the experimental conditions considered.
However, the study is limited to the reported laboratory results. Long-term durability, reinforcement corrosion, permeability and field exposure were not investigated. Further testing, including control concrete comparisons and statistical analysis, is recommended to validate the findings.
Conclusion
1) Among the tested GGBS mixtures, 50% replacement produced the highest reported 28-day compressive strength of 45.5 MPa.
2) Among the tested Fly Ash mixtures, 30% replacement produced the highest reported 28-day compressive strength of 41.5 MPa.
3) For GGBS concrete, the 28-day carbonation depth increased from 7 mm at 10% replacement to 12 mm at 70% replacement. The value at 50% replacement was 9 mm.
4) For Fly Ash concrete, the 28-day carbonation depth increased from 8.6 mm at 10% replacement to 10 mm at 30% and 40% replacement.
5) The results indicate that replacement percentage affects both compressive strength and carbonation depth. Selection of a suitable replacement level should therefore consider both strength and durability-related performance.
6) Within the reported test results, 50% GGBS is the preferred mixture when the criterion is the highest measured 28-day compressive strength among the tested mixtures. Further durability testing is required before making conclusions about long-term service life.
References
[1] N. Singh and S. P. Singh, “Study on concrete incorporating recycled aggregates and metakaolin,” Construction and Building Materials, vol. 121, pp. 400–409, 2016.
[2] S. Hussain, D. Bhunia and S. B. Singh, “Comparative study of accelerated carbonation of plain cement and fly-ash concrete,” Journal of Building Engineering, vol. 10, pp. 26–31, 2017.
[3] A. Pravalika and N. Venkat Rao, “A study on the effect of carbonation on the properties of concrete,” International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology, vol. 9, no. 7, pp. 1605–1611, 2018.
[4] J. J. Kim, K.-S. Youm and J. Moon, “Study on conversion fraction and carbonation of pozzolan blended concrete,” Applied Sciences, vol. 10, art. 6855, 2020.
[5] E. Gruyaert, P. Van den Heede and N. De Belie, “Study on the impact of cement replacement levels and curing duration on carbonation coefficient of concrete,” Cement and Concrete Composites, vol. 35, pp. 39–48, 2013.
[6] E. A. B. Khalil and M. Anwar, “A study on the carbonation of ternary cementitious concrete systems containing fly ash and silica fume,” 2014. [Publication details to be verified from the original source.]
[7] J. Zhao, E. D. Shumuye, Z. Wang and G. A. Bezabih, “A study on the performance of GGBS cement concrete under natural carbonation and accelerated carbonation exposure,” Journal of Engineering, art. 6659768, 2021.
[8] T. Sun et al., “Study on carbonation and compressive strength of concrete containing fly ash, GGBS, metakaolin and micro silica,” 2007. [Publication details to be completed.]
[9] BIS, IS 10262:2009, Concrete Mix Proportioning—Guidelines, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi, 2009.
[10] BIS, IS 383:1970, Specification for Coarse and Fine Aggregates from Natural Sources for Concrete, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi, 1970.