A tall building has to resist wind and earthquake forces in addition to the gravity loads, and as the height increases the lateral stiffness becomes the main design requirement. An outrigger system connects the lateral load resisting frame with the outer columns and helps in reducing the sway of the building without increasing the member sizes much. The location of the outrigger along the height has a direct effect on how well it works.
This paper presents the seismic analysis of a G+30 reinforced concrete building, about 93 m high, with a plan of 36 m x 36 m. Six models are studied: a bare frame, outrigger at storey 10, outrigger at storey 20, and outriggers at storeys 5 and 15, 10 and 20, and 15 and 25. Response spectrum analysis is carried out in ETABS for Seismic Zone V.
Storey displacement, base shear, time period, frequency, storey acceleration, storey drift, storey shear, torsion and bending moment are compared for all the models. The top displacement reduced by 8.2% to 21.6% and the top acceleration by 9.1% to 36.1% when outriggers were provided. The best performance was seen for the outriggers at storeys 15 and 25.
Introduction
In tall buildings, wind and earthquake forces become more important than gravity loads. These lateral forces cause storey displacement, drift, torsion, shear, and overturning moments.
A normal moment-resisting frame may not provide sufficient stiffness for very tall buildings. Therefore, structural systems such as shear walls, braced frames, tube systems, and outrigger systems are used to improve stability.
An outrigger system connects the central core of a building to the outer columns using stiff beams or braced trusses. It reduces lateral displacement and overturning moments by transferring forces to the outer columns.
2. Outrigger System
An outrigger is a stiff structural member that connects the central core with the exterior columns of a tall building.
Its main functions are:
Reduces lateral displacement caused by wind and earthquakes.
Reduces overturning moments.
Improves the lateral stiffness of the building.
Transfers forces from the central core to exterior columns.
Improves the overall stability of tall buildings.
The effectiveness of an outrigger depends on its stiffness, number, and location in the building.
3. Objectives of the Study
To model a G+30 reinforced concrete building in ETABS with and without outriggers.
To perform response spectrum analysis according to IS 1893 (Part 1):2016.
To compare storey displacement, base shear, time period, acceleration, drift, storey shear, torsion, and bending moment.
To study the effect of outrigger location and number.
To identify the most effective outrigger arrangement.
4. Literature Review
Previous researchers have studied different types of outrigger systems and their effects on tall buildings.
Gore and Mhatre (2018): Studied conventional, offset, and virtual outrigger systems.
Smith and Willford (2007): Introduced damped outrigger systems to reduce building vibrations.
Bhuta and Pareekh (2016): Compared shear wall, outrigger, and diagrid systems using ETABS.
Vellaichamy and Chakkaravarthi (2022): Studied the effect of outrigger location and depth on building performance.
Subramani and Murali (2018): Analysed outrigger and belt truss systems under wind and seismic loads.
Alhaddad (2020): Reviewed the effects of outrigger position, stiffness, and number.
Kavyashree et al. (2021): Reviewed the development of conventional, virtual, damped, and active outrigger systems.
Research Gap: Previous studies have examined different outrigger configurations, but further comparison is required to identify the most effective arrangement for the particular G+30 building considered in this study.
5. Methodology
A. Response Spectrum Analysis
Response spectrum analysis is a linear dynamic method used to determine the earthquake response of buildings.
It considers different modes of vibration and combines their maximum responses using methods such as:
SRSS (Square Root of Sum of Squares).
CQC (Complete Quadratic Combination).
In this project:
Earthquake analysis is performed according to IS 1893 (Part 1):2016.
Medium soil (Type II) is considered.
Damping ratio is 5%.
Wind loads are considered according to IS 875 (Part 3):2015.
ETABS software is used for modelling and analysis.
B. Model Specifications
The study considers a G+30 reinforced concrete building.
Parameter
Specification
Building type
G+30 storey
Concrete grade
M40
Steel grade
HYSD Fe550
Plan dimensions
36 m × 36 m
Grid spacing
4 m
Storey height
3 m
Total building height
Approximately 93 m
Beam size
300 × 450 to 600 × 750 mm
Column size
450 × 450 to 800 × 800 mm
Slab thickness
125–180 mm
Outrigger members
500 × 500 mm
Live load
3.5 kN/m²
Dead load
2.5 kN/m²
Seismic zone
V
Soil type
Type II (Medium soil)
Importance factor
1.5
Response reduction factor
5
Damping ratio
5%
Basic wind speed
39 m/s
C. Modelling Procedure in ETABS
The following steps are followed:
Define the building grid and storey heights.
Enter material properties of M40 concrete and Fe550 steel.
Define beam, column, and slab sections.
Assign structural members and slab elements.
Provide rigid diaphragms at every floor.
Apply dead, live, earthquake, and wind loads.
Define fixed support conditions at the base.
Define the mass source.
Add outrigger bracing at selected storey levels.
Perform structural analysis and compare the results.
6. Building Models Considered
Six different models are prepared in ETABS.
Model
Outrigger location
Number of levels
M1
No outrigger
0
M2
10th storey
1
M3
20th storey
1
M4
5th and 15th storeys
2
M5
10th and 20th storeys
2
M6
15th and 25th storeys
2
M1 is the reference model without outriggers. The other five models contain X-bracing members at the selected levels.
7. Results and Analysis
A. Comparison of Storey Displacement
The analysis shows that all outrigger models have lower storey displacement than the bare-frame model.
The top displacement results are:
Model
Top displacement
M1
32.68 mm
M2
30.01 mm
M6
25.61 mm
Key findings:
M1 has the maximum top displacement of 32.68 mm.
M2 reduces displacement by 8.2%.
M3 performs better than M2 among single-outrigger models.
M5 and M6 perform better than M4 among double-outrigger models.
M6 provides the maximum displacement reduction of 21.6%.
The top displacement of M6 is 25.61 mm.
Therefore, M6, with outriggers at the 15th and 25th storeys, gives the best displacement performance among the six models studied.
The displacement ratio improves from H/2855 in M1 to H/3643 in M6.
Conclusion
From this analysis the following conclusions were made
1) A G+30 reinforced concrete building was analysed by response spectrum analysis in ETABS as a bare frame and with five outrigger arrangements.
2) The top displacement reduced by 8.2% to 21.6% with outriggers. The maximum reduction was for the outriggers at storeys 15 and 25.
3) The top storey acceleration reduced by up to 36.1%, and the storey shear, torsion and bending moment at the base reduced by up to 35.7%, 35.7% and 34.5%, again for M6.
4) The fundamental time period reduced only by 0.6% to 2.9%, while the base shear increased by 0.3% to 4.8%. This small increase should be considered in the foundation design.
5) The maximum storey drift was not reduced by the outriggers and was within the code limit in all the models. The drift reduced only at the braced storeys.
6) Two outriggers gave better results than one, and outriggers in the upper part of the building were more effective than those in the lower part.
7) The reduction in top displacement per outrigger level was between 8.2% and 10.9%, so a second level did not double the benefit of a single well placed outrigger.
8) The present work is for a frame without core or shear wall and with one size of bracing member. Further work can be done with a core, different outrigger stiffness, belt trusses, wind load and time history analysis.
References
[1] N. G. Gore and P. Mhatre (2018), “Outrigger structural system: a review and comparison of the structural system”, International Journal of Engineering Trends and Technology, Vol. 64, No. 1, pp. 31-35.
[2] R. J. Smith and M. R. Willford (2007), “The damped outrigger concept for tall buildings”, The Structural Design of Tall and Special Buildings, Vol. 16, No. 4, pp. 501-517.
[3] D. C. Bhuta and U. Pareekh (2016), “Comparative study on lateral load resisting system in tall building”, International Journal of Science Technology & Engineering, Vol. 2, No. 11, pp. 320-327.
[4] P. Vellaichamy and V. Chakkaravarthi (2022), “Effect of outrigger systems for tall buildings”, Materials Today: Proceedings, Vol. 64, pp. 1129-1136.
[5] T. Subramani and K. Murali (2018), “Analytical study of tall building with outrigger system with respect to seismic and wind analysis using ETABS”, International Journal of Engineering and Technology.
[6] W. Alhaddad (2020), “Outrigger and belt-truss system design for high-rise buildings: a comprehensive review Part II”, Advances in Civil Engineering, Vol. 2020, Article 2589735.
[7] W. Alhaddad et al. (2020), “A comprehensive introduction to outrigger and belt-truss system in skyscrapers”, Structures, Vol. 27, pp. 989-998.
[8] B. G. Kavyashree, S. Patil and V. S. Rao (2021), “Evolution of outrigger structural system: a state-of-the-art review”, Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering, Vol. 46, pp. 10313-10331.
[9] IS 456:2000, Plain and Reinforced Concrete, Code of Practice, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
[10] IS 800:2007, General Construction in Steel, Code of Practice, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
[11] IS 875 (Part 3):2015, Design Loads (Other than Earthquake) for Buildings and Structures, Wind Loads, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
[12] IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structures, General Provisions and Buildings, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.