In a tall building the proportions of the plan matter as much as the height. The slenderness ratio, which is the height divided by the least plan dimension, decides how much the building sways and how strongly the overturning effect acts on the outer columns. A narrow tower has a smaller floor area and therefore attracts a smaller seismic force, but it is also more flexible, and these two effects work against each other.
This paper studies a G+40 storey reinforced concrete frame building, 123 m high, with a plan length of 24 m and four different widths of 25 m, 20 m, 15 m and 10 m. The slenderness ratios (H/B) are 4.92, 6.15, 8.2 and 12.3. The four models are analysed by response spectrum analysis in ETABS for Seismic Zone V, and the storey drift, storey shear, bending moment, torsion, time period and modal stiffness are compared.
When the width is reduced from 25 m to 10 m, the shear, bending moment and torsion at storey 6 reduce by 55% to 64%, because the seismic weight reduces. The drift in the Y direction, however, increases by 66% and crosses the limit of 0.004 at nine of the twenty storeys reported, and the first mode time period increases by 12%. A building with H/B of 12.3 therefore needs an additional lateral load resisting system.
Introduction
This study investigates the effect of the slenderness ratio on the seismic behaviour of tall reinforced concrete (RC) buildings. During an earthquake, lateral forces are generated due to the inertia of the building and are transferred through slabs, beams, columns, and foundations to the ground. The seismic performance of a building depends not only on its strength and stiffness but also on its geometric configuration, particularly its height, plan dimensions, and slenderness ratio.
The slenderness ratio is defined as the ratio of the total building height to its least lateral plan dimension (H/B). This study examines how changes in building width influence seismic response while keeping the building height and length constant.
Objectives of the Study
To model a G+40 reinforced concrete building using ETABS with four different plan widths.
To investigate four slenderness ratios: 4.92, 6.15, 8.2, and 12.3.
To perform response spectrum analysis for Seismic Zone V.
To compare storey drift, storey shear, bending moment, torsion, time period, and modal stiffness.
To evaluate the influence of slenderness ratio on seismic demand and building serviceability.
Research Methodology
The study uses Response Spectrum Analysis, a linear dynamic analysis method that evaluates the maximum structural response through different vibration modes. The analysis is performed in ETABS using the IS 1893 (Part 1):2002 design response spectrum for medium soil conditions (Type II) and 5% damping. Twelve vibration modes are considered for each building model.
A G+40 reinforced concrete building with a total height of 123 m is modelled using the following specifications:
Concrete grade: M40.
Steel grade: HYSD Fe600.
Plan length: 24 m.
Plan widths: 25 m, 20 m, 15 m, and 10 m.
Total number of storeys: G+40.
Storey height: 3 m.
Seismic zone: V.
Importance factor: 1.5.
Response reduction factor: 5.
Damping ratio: 5%.
Four building models are developed by changing only the plan width while maintaining the same height, length, material properties, structural member sizes, and loading conditions.
Building Models Considered
Model
Plan dimensions (m)
Slenderness ratio (H/B)
Plan area
Model 1
24 × 25
4.92
600 m²
Model 2
24 × 20
6.15
480 m²
Model 3
24 × 15
8.20
360 m²
Model 4
24 × 10
12.30
240 m²
Model 1 represents the widest and least slender building, whereas Model 4 represents the narrowest and most slender building.
Modelling and Loading Procedure
The four building models are developed in ETABS by defining the grid system, storey heights, material properties, beam and column sections, and slab dimensions. Rigid diaphragms are assigned at each floor, and all columns are fixed at the base.
Dead load, live load, earthquake load, and wind load are considered during the analysis. The earthquake loading is defined according to IS 1893 (Part 1):2002, while wind loading is considered according to IS 875 (Part 3):1987. Response spectrum analysis is conducted separately in both the X and Y directions to evaluate the structural response.
Results and Analysis
The study compares the seismic responses of all four models using twenty selected storeys. The results are evaluated with respect to Model 1, which has a slenderness ratio of 4.92.
The main parameters considered for comparison are:
Storey displacement and storey drift.
Storey shear.
Bending moment.
Torsional response.
Fundamental time period.
Modal stiffness.
The analysis aims to understand how reducing the building width and increasing the slenderness ratio affect the overall seismic performance, structural stability, and serviceability of tall buildings.
Conclusion
From this analysis the following conclusions were made
1) A G+40 reinforced concrete building was analysed by response spectrum analysis for four plan widths, which give slenderness ratios of 4.92, 6.15, 8.2 and 12.3.
2) The storey shear, bending moment and torsion reduce as the width reduces. At storey 6 the reductions for the narrowest building are 55.5% and 61.6% in shear, 63.5% and 55.2% in bending and 61.6% in torsion. The reduction follows the reduction in the floor area, because the seismic weight becomes less.
3) The storey drift in the X direction reduces by 21.6% as the width reduces, but the drift in the Y direction increases by 15.1%, 34.4% and 66.3% for Models 2, 3 and 4.
4) The drift in the Y direction of the building with H/B = 12.3 is more than the limit of 0.004 at nine of the twenty storeys reported. The building with H/B = 8.2 is close to the limit, and the buildings with H/B of 4.92 and 6.15 satisfy it.
5) The first mode time period is 12.1% more for the building with H/B = 12.3 than for the building with H/B = 4.92. The higher modes are nearly the same for all the models.
6) The lower forces in the slender buildings are because of their smaller weight and not because of better behaviour. The slenderness ratio should be checked against the drift limit, and not only against the forces.
7) For the frame studied here, the slenderness ratio of about 8 is the practical limit. A building with a higher ratio needs a wider plan, larger members or an additional lateral load resisting system such as shear walls or bracing.
8) The study is for a bare frame without any lateral load resisting system other than the frame itself.
References
[1] C. Arnold and R. Reitherman (1982), Building Configuration and Seismic Design, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
[2] C. V. R. Murty (2005), IITK-BMTPC Earthquake Tips: Learning Earthquake Design and Construction, National Information Center of Earthquake Engineering, IIT Kanpur, India.
[3] S. A. Sanyal (2008), “Multi-dimensional building planning for safer tomorrow”, Proceedings of the 14th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Beijing, China.
[4] T. A. Awida et al. (2011), “Slenderness ratio influence on the structural behavior of residential concrete tall buildings”, Journal of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Vol. 5, No. 6, pp. 527-534.
[5] S. K. Sadh and U. Pendharkar (2016), “Influence of aspect ratio and plan configurations on seismic performance of multistoreyed regular R.C.C. buildings: an evaluation by response spectrum analysis”, International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, Vol. 3, No. 1.
[6] IS 456:2000, Plain and Reinforced Concrete, Code of Practice, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
[7] IS 800:2007, General Construction in Steel, Code of Practice, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
[8] IS 875 (Part 3):1987, Code of Practice for Design Loads (Other than Earthquake) for Buildings and Structures, Wind Loads, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
[9] IS 1893 (Part 1):2002, Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structures, General Provisions and Buildings, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.